Plus, they have a bit more to think about at the moment, based on current results....anyway, here it is.
8 May 2019
Dear Mr Venkatesham
I am once again writing to you as an Arsenal fan to ask you to change the name of Arsenal’s First Team to Arsenal Men.
As I explained in my letter dated 14 February 2019, for the past few years I have been writing to Arsenal’s former Chief Executive, Ivan Gazidis, to advocate for this change. I believe that you are the person at the club to approach about this, but please forward this letter on to someone else if that would be appropriate.
After the Brighton game on Sunday, I was struck by the number of times the phrase ‘first team’ was used to describe the Men’s First Team. This was despite the fact that the women were in attendance as newly-crowned league champions, for the first time in nine years and in the first year in which the women’s top division has been entirely professional. I felt that the inappropriateness of the term was very evident, and I believe that I will not have been the only one.
This is an example of the phenomenon of ‘male default’, described in detail by Caroline Criado Perez in her latest book, Invisible Women (published in March). It assumes the male experience is the universal human experience, and that women are secondary.
The book outlines many examples of the damaging effect this can produce in a number of environments. Although Arsenal is proud of its women’s team, the club says that it has a ‘first’ team, and it is the men’s team. They are senior to the women’s team (they are ‘first’ after all), better than them, more central to what football is because they are what ‘normal’ football is. They are made to seem universal, but are of course as gendered as women’s football. They should be ‘Men’ and ‘Women’, not ‘First’ and ‘Women’. The former is exactly the way that Manchester City and Chelsea describe their teams, so Arsenal - the league champions, having beaten City and Chelsea to that title - are now lagging behind.
Yes, it is the ‘First Team’ because there are reserve and Academy teams. But they are stepping stones to the top men’s team. Arsenal Women are not a stepping stone to Arsenal Men, so Arsenal Men cannot be the ‘first’ team. Indeed, they both have reserve and youth teams, so the names really do cease to make much sense. They are legacies of a past in which women’s football was ignored or outright banned, as it effectively was until 1971.
This is even more stark in the light of this summer’s World Cup, which is likely to see a further explosion of interest in and support of the women’s game. The timing is perfect to make this change, but the window is closing fast.
Society is made up of everyone and everything. Each person and organisation needs to take their own responsibility for the signals they create. I’m sure you do not need me to tell you that not only are Arsenal Football Club no different, they are a huge, globally recognised institution. What we do, what football clubs like Arsenal do for sport, is to help set a tone for society. They are big bricks in the wall of society. The way to change perceptions is for each individual person and organisation to look at what they can do to help, or what they are doing that is not helpful, especially now that other teams are leaving Arsenal behind.
If Arsenal Football Club believe that its men’s and women’s teams are part of the same club, then this is the opportunity to prove it, and avoid being last to do so. To prove that we are indeed ahead of the game, and worthy of our great champions who have just won the Women’s Super League.
Yours in optimism,
Martin Cordiner
No comments:
Post a Comment